PanemHungerGames.com Reivew of the Hunger Games Movie

Discussion in 'Hunger Games News' started by Brienne, Mar 23, 2012.

  • Sneaky
    • Administrator

    Brienne Administrator

    Member Since:
    Dec 7, 2011
    Message Count:
    558
    Gender:
    Female
    Location:
    Orange County, CA
    Ratings Received:
    +212
    Last night was the midnight release of the Hunger Games, and I was fortunate enough, well awake enough, to see the movie. I arrived at the theater parking lot around 5:30pm and found my place in line for the next six and a half hours. For those of you keeping me company on Twitter, I thank you for helping me pass the time. I really did get a lot of tweet pictures of people doing the same thing I was doing all across the country. :) I will make another post containing all the pictures I received!

    395898_390949417588382_159746560708670_1810196_783431397_n.jpg

    First, the casting choices are spot on. I know a lot of fans had their reservations about certain actors or actresses (I know I had mine), but I am here to tell you that the cast pretty much nailed each one of their characters. Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson as leads in the movie really portrayed the pain their characters are going through during the course of the movie. Jennifer has a number of really moving scenes (hi, Rue) where she brought audience members around me to tears, so don't feel bad if you got choked up by some of her performances. Josh plays Peeta perfectly. From the look on his face during the Reaping to the interview before the arena, Josh's portrayal of the beloved Peeta is amazing. Also worth mentioning, Liam Hemsworth only had a few scenes, but he did a great job in each of them. The supporting cast members really rounded out the performances. Woody Harrelson (Haymitch), Elizabeth Banks (Effie), Stanley Tucci (Caesar), Wes Bentley (Senaca) and Donald Sutherland (President Snow) all gave wonderful performances. As a character side note, I do love the flirtatious relationship that seems to be developing between Haymitch and Effie.

    405481_390949257588398_159746560708670_1810190_1667510260_n.jpg

    The sets for the Hunger Games were well done. Gary Ross and his team did a tremendous job making District 12 look the way it felt while reading the book. District 12 looked like a rundown Southern mining town that was on the brink of collapse and destruction. The Capitol is filled with people who care only about themselves and the way they look. Every part of the Capitol is filled with excessiveness in a utopian metropolis. The arena is a vast forested battleground that is scattered with trip and tricks from the Gamemakers. Visually, the whole movie is appealing and easy on the eyes to watch. There is not an overuse of CGI, and the CGI that is in the movie looks realistic and well placed.

    409508_390949267588397_159746560708670_1810191_1039986248_n.jpg

    The director, Gary Ross, put on a clinic for how to keep movies upbeat and fast moving. I wasn’t bored for a minute because I really didn’t have time to dwell on mundane details before we were moving on to the next scene. However, there was time I felt a little rushed and yearned for just a little more character development. But I will sacrifice a few character tidbits for a fast moving, high octane film any day of the week. I know a lot of people were worried about the PG-13 rating and how the violence was going to look on the big screen, but Gary Ross pulled it off without a hitch. Just like he said in a number of interviews, he doesn’t overuse violence or exploit violence. The audience is going to understand kids are killing kids, so extra blood and gore would have been unnecessary.

    426218_390949464255044_159746560708670_1810198_989250724_n.jpg

    Finally, as the credits started to roll, I found myself sitting in my theater chair smiling with happy thoughts that my favorite franchise is in good hands. Is Lionsgate, Gary Ross and the rest of the crew going to make perfect decisions about translating the book to the big screen? No. But, I don’t need perfect. I need great and that is what I watched last night, a GREAT movie. If you haven’t seen the movie yet, let the book go. Come into the theater with an open mind and don’t spend too much time worry about what is there and what isn’t there. If you do this, you will have a great experience and left wanting more…

    My Grade: A- / B+

    SPOILERS AHEAD! I am going to be talking about scenes/situations that were cut from the movie and scenes/situations that were changed in the movie. If you haven't seen the movie, proceed at your own risk! If you haven't read the books or seen the movie, I would not recommend reading any further! Also, I do not hate the movie. The purpose of sharing this information is to create discussions on some small aspects of the movie. I loved this movie and am eagerly awaiting the second installment in this GREAT franchise.

    Haymitch Falling off the Stage at the Reaping
    This was one scene that I was looking forward to before we got into the Reaping. While reading the books, we were able to understand that Haymitch was trying to forget or get over something through alcohol. He was described as the town drunk that culminated into him falling off the stage during his Reaping speech. I am sure Gary Ross left this out of the movie because it didn't fit the tone or theme that he chooses to go with. The comical aspect of this scene would not have fit with how the Reaping was portrayed during the movie.

    Peeta & Katniss Confronting Haymitch on the Train
    This was "sort of" in the movie but not even close to the way it felt in the book. In the book, Haymitch jokes about the advice he gives to Katniss & Peeta, "Here's some advice. Stay alive." He says this while laughing which upsets Peeta, "That's very funny, only not to us." Peeta slaps a drink out of Haymitch's hand and receives a punch to the face from Haymitch. When Haymitch tries to reach for another drink, Katniss drives a knife into the table right between his fingers. Haymitch finishes the scenes with, "Well what's this? Did I actually get a pair of fighters this year?" What are your thoughts as to why this scene was taken out of the movie?

    The Bread from District 11
    After the death of Rue and Katniss shows District 11 just how much she cared for Rue, District 11 sends a parachute of bread to Katniss as a thank you message. Was this taken out of the movie because they didn't explain different bread types during training? In the books, Peeta breaks down the different types of bread from each District. However, I feel that this scene might have been replaced by the District 11 riot scene that was added to lay the ground work for 'Catching Fire'.

    The Sleep Syrup to Knock Peeta Out
    This one stung a little. It was one of my favorite interactions between Katniss & Peeta during their time in the arena. A feast was called to get tributes to meet up at the Cornucopia to get an item they most needed. Even though Katniss says she wasn't going to go, Peeta knows she is lying, "You're such a bad liar, Katniss. ... Never gamble at cards. You'll lose your last coin." Peeta was insistant on Katniss not going. If she did, he would hobble out of the cave screaming and yelling to draw attention to himself and away from Katniss. Eventually, Katniss agrees not to go and decides to go outside to think. When she gets outside, a parachute is waiting for her. It is filled with sweet syrup that will knock Peeta out for 24 hours. After mixing it in with some berries, she feeds it to Peeta, knocking him out. The part that makes this scene great is what she says next, "Who can't lie, Peeta?"

    Katniss Injuring her Left Ear while Destroying the Career Supplies
    Not a huge detail, but something that could have been in there without taking much time to explain. When Katniss blows up the career supplies, she severly injures her ear to the point she cannot really hear out of it. Her ear gets fixed after the games are over and has a minor plot point in 'Catching Fire'. I wonder if this is going to have a ripple effect on the next movie.

    Peeta's Leg Injury
    This was another part of the book that was "sort of" in the movie. Yes, Peeta got his leg injured, but it healed completely once the cream was applied to the injury. (The movie changed the injection to cream.) Fixing Peeta's leg completely made the finishing scene of the arena feel less tense. I couldn't read the book fast enough, when he ripped the tunicate off and stated he was going to bleed to death so Katniss could win.

    The Mutated Mutts
    These were in the movie, but not even close to the mental image I had in my head. Maybe the CGI department couldn't get the book version to look right on the big screen, or they simply were not in the budget for the movie. Whatever the case may be, the twistedness of the Capitol came through the pages when Katniss realized the Mutts contained the eyes of the fallen tributes. The Mutts in the movie literally looked like Mutts(dogs) but much bigger. With that logic, I could call my dog, Matilda, a Mutt because she is small. (I call her that anyways when she does something bad!) I really wanted to feel how sick the Capitol really is with their mutation of the fallen tributes.

    Katniss' Freak Out in the Hovercraft after Winning the Games
    A very emotional scene on paper, that didn't end up in the movie. After being picked up from the arena in the hovercraft, Peeta is whisked away to another room for emergency medical treatment. Katniss is cut off from Peeta and in a glass holding cell. While watching Peeta get medical attention, Katniss is yelling for Peeta, throwing her whole body against the glass to try and get to Peeta, someone she deeply cares for. The reader felt the growing bound between Katniss and Peeta reading those words, but it was left out of the movie. This scene is directly related to Peeta's injury that was changed from the book version.

    In conclusion, there were a number of scenes that I wanted to see that were removed from the movie for one reason or another. However, when translating a book to the big screen, cuts have to be made. The sad part is that sometimes they have to be deep cuts. How long would the movie of been without these cuts? 3 Hours? I know Gary Ross said they stayed true to the source material, and when looking at the movie as a whole, they did. They really nailed the negative/inhumane nature of the Hunger Games and the desperate state of the District citizens of Panem. I just wanted some "more" icing on the cake or maybe that cherry that goes on top. The relationship between Katniss and Peeta was very important to me while reading the book, and I just didn't get that same feeling while watching the movie.

    All in all, as far as book translations go, I feel the movie was successful. They took one of my favorite books and made a good movie that moved very fast and never felt boring. I will be watching this in the theater again before I get the movie on Blu-ray. Then, it is time to play the waiting game for 500+ days for Catching Fire! Who's with me????

    PS - Sorry if something is spell wrong or my grammar is off! I am running on 3 hours of sleep, 4 cups of coffee and trying to do some work! :(
    • Like Like x 4

Comments

Discussion in 'Hunger Games News' started by Brienne, Mar 23, 2012.

  1. TheGirlOnFire
    Loved this review Brienne. I agree with basically everything that you said. I really did love the movie though, so like you stated, I am only critiquing.
    ~I'd love to discuss the reason for cutting out important aspects to the cave scene.
    ~Also, I was a little hurt that they didn't give Josh Hutcherson blue contacts. I had just reread the book before the movie and was really excited about his shinny blue eyes peeking out from his camouflage (which btw, was INCREDIBLE in the movie. I litterally did not see him there for the LONGEST time).
    ~ I also didn't like the way the film ended in the train with Katniss and Peeta. I felt that in the book, Peeta was much more shocked and defeated that Katniss had only been pretending and Katniss was confused that Peeta had not been. In the movie, if you had not read the books beforehand, it was easily construed as Katniss only wanting to forget the death and suffering from the games and Peeta wanting to remember their love.
    ~Lastly, I was a little bit disappointed in the cheese-factor of the green screen Capitol during the opening ceremonies with the horse drawn chariots. I thought that Peeta and Katniss looked dazzling, but the background green screen kind of ruined the whole effect for me.

    Thoughts?
    • Like Like x 1
  2. Brienne
    You definitely bring up some valid points. Some that I wanted to touch on but if I added anymore my review would be over 2,000 words! :p

    It had to be a time constraint. The movie was very fast paced. It would of been hard even adding 5 minutes and getting so close to that 2.5 hour mark.

    I am not sure why they didn't do this either. I mean if you are changing hair color, you might as well change the eye color as well.

    Your point here has a much deeper impact on their relationship as a whole. In a number of interviews Gary Ross stated that he didn't want to dwell on the relationship/love triangle part of the book. He succeeded but it will sadden the fans that really attached themselves to that part of the book.

    This comes down to time and money and was probably a decision that Lionsgate made. I am hoping with Catching Fire, the budget is bigger and the timeframe is MUCH longer.
  3. TheGirlOnFire
    AGREE, but still sad.
    AGREE, it wouldn't have been that hard right?
    AGREE, but I thought that that particular aspect was EXTREMELY important to everything about The Hunger Games!
    AGREE, I just wish it hadn't been that way. And I hope that Catching Fire doesn't have to do so much green-screening.

    I missed not seeing a more intense scene on the train between Haymitch and the tributes. It was too low key.
    Oh and I decided that I really didn't like Haymitch asked Seneca Crane to make a rule change for two winners.
    • Like Like x 1
  4. TheGirlOnFire
    ALSO, parts of the movie when my whole movie theater reacted together and I thought it was very moving and emotional to be connected to my theater and the movie in that way:

    ~We all giggled when we saw Gale watching Katniss and Peeta kiss two or three times. Even though I don't think it was supposed to be funny.
    ~ We all jumped when the first cannon sounded.
    ~ We ALL jumped at literally the same time when the first mutt dog jumped out.
    ~ We pretty much all got teary eyed or cried when Katniss was crying over Rue.
    • Like Like x 1
  5. FireCatcher
    Wow, great review! :)
    I have to agree with pratically everything you and TheGirlOnFire said.
    -Amazing adaptation.
    - Some very good changes (some not that good)
    - Fantastic cast!
    - What was that last Cato's scene? The changes in his last speech were brilliant!
    - I won't even comment those incredible scenarios.
    - I liked the scenes in the Districts much more than I thought I would.
    - Gary's direction was so spectacular that you feel like you're actually in the movie. You feel the tension like it was all real through the camera effects and all the small details Gary brings to life.The presentation of scenes like the one in District 11 after Rue's death made me see that changes from the book to the screen are not always bad. I loved that because I felt like it was Gary's way of saying: "Hey, take a look at what is going to happen in the next movies, but in higher proportions".
    - Ok, guys, it's a fact: Jennifer Lawrence IS Katniss <3
    - Awesome soundtrack.
    - Two things I would change:
    1. Haymitch: I totally loved Woody, but I didn't see that brutal love between him and Katniss. Besides, I was looking forward to the " Here's some advice. Stay alive" D:
    2. Katniss + Peeta: as TheGirlOnFire said, I don't think the movie explored the fact that Peeta is really in love and Katniss was just playing the game to stay alive. In the end I had the sensation Katniss could actually love him and Gale and be just confused about that. I think this whole "love game" thing was understimated.
    • Like Like x 1
  6. Brienne
    I wonder if that came directly from Suzanne Collins. I know she was very involved with writing the script with Gary. So I am wondering if he simply asked where Senaca got that idea. hhmmm... I wonder...
    • Like Like x 1
  7. Brienne
    haha... I know what you are talking about! The whole theater laughed when Peeta asked for Katniss' bow, LOL. "Just kidding, I will go gather some roots..." :p

    And my audience gave a sympathetic sigh to watching Gale watch Katniss and Peeta, hehe.
    • Like Like x 1
  8. TheGirlOnFire
    HAHA YES! That just might be my favorite line from the movie.
    And we also sighed during the only really big, really climatic kiss in the cave scene.
    • Like Like x 2
  9. Brienne
    I absolutely agree. I really wanted to see the transformation in the relationship between Katniss and Haymitch.

    Yeah, it was the general direction/style the movie was taken. I wonder if they are going to play it up a little more in 'Catching Fire'.
    • Like Like x 2
  10. Lucyyy!
    Great review, the points you made were practically spot on to what my friends and I were discussing afterwards.
    I was especially disappointed that Haymitch's entrance to the reaping wasn't in there but I can see why they did it because I'm sure in a short space of time they wouldn't have been able to portray Katniss's relief and why, also the pure shock of the volunteering would have been ruined!
    In was especially surprised to see the cornucopia, I reaalllyy didn't imagine it like that! o_O
    The bond between Peeta and Katniss surprised me, because I read the books I left knowing that Katniss was acting to keep herself and Peeta alive whereas Peeta was genuinely in love with her but this wasn't well shown in the film, but perhaps it will be explained in Catching Fire?
    The bond between Haymitch and Katniss was strange, they got on too well for my liking haha!! So different from the book where they didn't get along with each other.
    But overall I absolutely loved the film!! I was wearing my Hunger games Tshirt dressed for the part :p I found my self leaning forwards, hand over mouth, jaws dropping, jumping in many scenes (especially the mutts :p), crying in others, tensing up, sighing of relief and 'aw'ing' in others. I have booked another ticket to go again on Sunday. Gary Ross and then cast have done a brilliant job!! :D
    • Like Like x 1
  11. Fan4me
    I'm gonna respond to each of the "complaint" paragraphs in the review in number order.

    1. I'm glad they removed Haymitch's drunk reaping appearance. It would have came off cheesy. The way the reaping was dead silent in the movie had to stay that way. Humor would've been cheesy.
    2. I had actually forgot about how the confrontation with Haymitch went so that didn't affect me during the movie but now that you brought it up, I do think that would've been good in the movie. They should've kept it.
    3. On the bread thing, I'm glad they changed that. The movie was fine without it and it just would've been an extra few minutes of explaining the breads when it really wasn't necessary for the story.
    4. On the sleep syrup part, i'm glad again they removed that. I think if they got another sponsor gift, it would seem like a little too much. Like they were just getting everything they needed. It was easier and quicker for Katniss to just leave while he's sleeping.
    5. I LOVED the ringing in the ear effect!!! That was so cool feeling just like Katniss. But they just kind of ignored it after that. They should have kept her hearing loss in the movie.
    6. I don't remember Peeta's leg injury affecting the end of the book at all. It didn't matter to me in the movie that it healed quickly.
    7. As for the Mutts, I would've preferred more crazy looking beasts too. However, it was smart of them in my opinion to remove the fact that the beasts looked like the fallen tributes. I don't think everyone would've caught on to that if you hadn't read the books.
    8. Katniss's freakout would've been good to include. The movie would've been like 10 minutes longer though.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    I thought this movie was amazing in the end and it's my new favorite movie ever. I'm so affected.
    • Like Like x 4
  12. Chaa
    @Brienne wow! I am so impressed with this review! It's crazy to see your exact thoughts on paper (or in this case screen) when someone else wrote them. This is exactly what my mom and I thought about the movie. I also agree with what @TheGirlOnFire thought. Also, I'm curious to see what you thought of Cinna. I thought that his and Katniss's relationship was very important to the story an that they didn't develop it nearly enough. They also didn't develop the relationship between her and Peeta or between her and Haymitch. I thought that Stanley Tucci was FABULOUS as Caesar and that Liam Hemworth was perfect for Gale. I loved all of the characters with a few exceptions. Rue did not meet my expectations despite all of the love an admiration she is receiving from fans. Maybe it was due to the fact that the relationship between Katniss and Rue was not nearly developed enough. Cinna also did not meet my expectations. And I LOVED the cave scene and the hovercraft scene in the book and was so sad that the former was not developed enough in the movie and that the latter wasnt even in it! One more thing. PEETA WASN'T FUNNY ENOUGH!! Did anyone else think that?
  13. Lucyyy!
    I think that the film focused too much on the action, the importance of the relationships that Katniss forms was almost dismissed? I know they were restricted of time but the people who didn't read the book are going to have missed out on this..
    • Like Like x 3

Share This Page